Ohio Valley
- Square sheet pizza, sold by the cut
- Crust baked with sauce
- Cold provolone + toppings go on AFTER the oven
- The box steam melts it a little
- Born in Steubenville, OH, 1945 (DiCarlo's)
Ohio Valley pizza 🧀
Ohio Valley pizza is a square sheet pizza with cold provolone put on after the oven. It was born at DiCarlo's in Steubenville, OH (1945). We list 4 checked spots, all $.
What is it?
Hot square. Cold cheese.
How it helps
See the spot and the $. Go in one tap.
Why trust us
We never make up ratings. Miles come from street addresses.
Easy next step
Tap Maps or Waze. Or Find my pizza.
Where to go
- Steubenville · the first
DiCarlo's Original Pizza
📍 318 Adams St, Steubenville, OH 43952$ · Where it started. Order by the cut. - Wheeling · since 1949
DiCarlo's Pizza — Downtown
📍 1311 Main St, Wheeling, WV 26003$ · Trays or cuts. Grab and go. - Glen Dale, WV
DiCarlo's Pizza — Glen Dale
📍 1720 Wheeling Ave, Glen Dale, WV 26038$ · Same cold-cheese squares. - Elm Grove, Wheeling
Patsy's Pizza
📍 2099 National Rd, Wheeling, WV 26003$ · Ohio Valley squares. Closed Mon–Tue (Yelp).
What is Ohio Valley pizza?
🏠 Make it at home
Bake crust + sauce on a sheet pan till golden (hot oven). Right away add cold shredded provolone and pepperoni. Close the lid 2 minutes.
Quick answers
What is Ohio Valley pizza?
Ohio Valley pizza is a square sheet pizza with cold provolone put on after the oven.
Why is the cheese cold?
That is the style. The crust bakes with sauce, then cold provolone and toppings go on after the oven. Steam in the box melts it a little.
How much is pizza at these Ohio Valley spots?
Our checked spots here are $. $ is cheap (under about $15), $$ is moderate (about $15–$25), $$$ is a splurge ($25+), for a typical pie.
Can I make it at home?
Bake crust + sauce on a sheet pan till golden (hot oven). Right away add cold shredded provolone and pepperoni. Close the lid 2 minutes.
Why trust PIZZA OG?
We check every spot by hand on official sites and map listings. We never make up ratings or reviews. On Find my pizza, miles are counted from each spot's street address.
More guides
Spots checked by hand on official sites and map listings (Sep 2026). Hours change: check Maps before you go.