Old Forge
- Order a TRAY, not a pie
- Cut in squares — called “cuts”
- Red tray: sauce + cheese
- White: double crust, often rosemary
- Old Forge, PA (near Scranton)
Old Forge pizza 🟧
Old Forge pizza is a tray pizza cut in squares (“cuts”), red or white, from Old Forge, PA. Try Revello's, Arcaro & Genell, Ghigiarelli's or Salerno's Cafe. All are $$.
What is it?
Pizza Capital of the World.
How it helps
See the spot and the $. Go in one tap.
Why trust us
We never make up ratings. Miles come from street addresses.
Easy next step
Tap Maps or Waze. Or Find my pizza.
Where to go
- Pizza Row · S Main St
Revello's Pizza
📍 502 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518$$ · Red tray + double-crust white. - Pizza Row · S Main St
Arcaro & Genell
📍 443 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518$$ · Red, white and peasant trays. Call ahead: takeout-first right now. - Pizza Row · since 1926
Ghigiarelli's
📍 511 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518$$ · Back in 2026. Takeout window. Sells out — go early. - Moosic Rd
Salerno's Cafe
📍 139 Moosic Rd, Old Forge, PA 18518$$ · Red, white and stuffed white. Sit-down.
What is Old Forge pizza?
🏠 Make it at home
Oil a sheet pan. Press dough to the corners. Sauce, then cheese. Bake hot till the bottom is crisp. Cut in squares.
Quick answers
What is Old Forge pizza?
Old Forge pizza is a tray pizza cut in squares (“cuts”), red or white, from Old Forge, PA.
How do I order Old Forge pizza?
Order a tray, not a pie. It comes cut in squares called cuts. Red tray = sauce + cheese. White = double crust, often with rosemary.
How much is pizza at these Old Forge spots?
Our checked spots here are $$. $ is cheap (under about $15), $$ is moderate (about $15–$25), $$$ is a splurge ($25+), for a typical pie.
Can I make it at home?
Oil a sheet pan. Press dough to the corners. Sauce, then cheese. Bake hot till the bottom is crisp. Cut in squares.
Why trust PIZZA OG?
We check every spot by hand on official sites and map listings. We never make up ratings or reviews. On Find my pizza, miles are counted from each spot's street address.
More guides
Spots checked by hand on official sites and map listings (Sep 2026). Hours change: check Maps before you go.